Flu vaccines may be less effective than commonly believed, but that is no reason to skip an annual flu shot. This was the conclusion reached by researchers at the University of Maryland. Their findings were published in the journal JAMA Network Open.
The scientists analyzed vaccine effectiveness estimates across 20 flu seasons, from 2004–2005 through 2023–2024. They also examined how closely vaccine formulations matched the virus strains that actually circulated each season.
The median vaccine effectiveness in preventing infection was 39.5%—slightly below the frequently cited range of 40–60%. The median value means that effectiveness was higher in some seasons and lower in others.
In addition, in 11 of the 18 seasons for which the researchers assessed how well vaccines matched circulating strains, the vaccines were not a good match for the prevalent virus variants.
“The range of 40% to 60% may describe some seasons, but it does not fully capture fluctuations in effectiveness over time,” said senior study author Justin Ortiz, a researcher at the University of Maryland's Center for Vaccine Development and Global Health.
At the same time, the researchers stress that vaccination remains the most effective available way to prevent flu. According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), flu causes between 6,300 and 52,000 deaths annually.
During the 2023–2024 season, vaccination helped prevent an estimated 7,900 deaths, 120,000 hospitalizations and 9.8 million cases of illness, according to the CDC. Flu began spreading early this season; according to figures cited in the publication, around 2,100 people had already died from it by the time the article was prepared.
The authors hope the findings will help improve vaccines so that they provide broader and more predictable protection against the constantly changing virus.
“Annual flu vaccination remains our best option for now as we continue developing vaccines that provide more predictable and longer-lasting protection,” said lead study author Matthew Wolpert, a resident physician at the University of Maryland Medical Center.










