Genetic predisposition may influence how strongly diet affects levels of “bad” cholesterol and cardiovascular disease risk in women. This was the conclusion reached by researchers at Stanford University. The findings were published in the journal JACC: Advances.
The scientists analyzed data from more than 21,000 American women collected over several decades as part of the large-scale Women's Health Initiative study. Participants regularly reported on their diets, had their cholesterol levels checked, and underwent genetic testing.
The researchers found that certain genetic characteristics were associated with higher levels of low-density lipoprotein (LDL), known as “bad” cholesterol. This association was particularly pronounced in women who consumed large amounts of saturated fat.
Among participants with the strongest genetic predisposition to high LDL levels—the quarter of women with the highest genetic risk—a diet high in saturated fat was also associated with an increased risk of heart attack and stroke. This association was weaker in women with a less pronounced predisposition.
According to the study's senior author, Stanford University cardiologist Shoa Clarke, this does not mean that dietary changes are pointless for people with an unfavorable genetic profile. On the contrary, diet may have a particularly pronounced effect—both positive and negative—in people genetically predisposed to high cholesterol.
The researchers also found no evidence that higher saturated fat intake protects the heart, even in people with a relatively low genetic predisposition to high LDL levels. This contradicts claims made by proponents of certain high-fat diets, including the ketogenic diet.
The authors note that differences in individual responses to saturated fat may explain conflicting views in debates over how much of it is acceptable in the diet. However, there is not yet enough evidence to use genetic risk assessments to develop personalized dietary recommendations.
The scientists next plan to investigate whether genetic tests can help identify more precisely who would benefit most from dietary changes. The researchers emphasize that genetic predisposition does not make the effects of diet inevitable, and that higher saturated fat intake has no proven benefits for heart health.










